Facebook can’t use your sexual orientation to target ads, EU court says

Targeted ads may seem like a no-brainer, but safety and privacy considerations complicate the issue.
By  on 
A user scans Facebook on their phone.
Europe is putting limits on how Meta uses data on sexual orientation. Credit: d3sign via Getty Images

Meta cannot target a user’s sexual orientation in its personalized ads — even if they are openly queer and make public statements about the subject, the European Union’s highest court ruled Friday.

The case was brought from longtime Meta antagonist Max Schrems, as Wired reports. The Austrian activist, whose separate privacy case recently led to a $1.3 billion fine against the company, claimed in this case that Meta broke EU privacy laws by pulling data on his sexual orientation via website visits, app logins, and other sources outside of Facebook, using all that data to target him with LGBTQ-specific ads.

Meta denies it engages in this practice. The company says it considers information on sexual orientation sensitive, and doesn’t indiscriminately include it in its advertising efforts.

When Schrems first took his claim to court, an Austrian judge ruled Meta has a right to target Schrems with ads related to his sexual orientation since he previously discussed being gay during a public panel discussion. But the judge also sent Schrems' case up to the EU legal system for its ruling.

Now the Court of Justice of the European Union has disagreed with the Austrian court, saying public statements aren’t a green light for tech companies like Meta to target sensitive ads to users.

Mashable Light Speed
Want more out-of-this world tech, space and science stories?
Sign up for Mashable's weekly Light Speed newsletter.
By clicking Sign Me Up, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up!

The EU court also backed up Schrems’ assertion that Meta just doesn't pull data from users’ activity on their social media services, but also considers their behavior elsewhere on the internet.

'Meta's data pool is growing every day'

Even if Meta can detect that a user is queer from their online or offline activities, the court said, they cannot take that information and use it to target them with personalized advertising. 

In a statement, Meta said it takes privacy very seriously. The company added that it offers settings for users to control how information about them is used.

Schrems' lawyer, Katharina Raabe-Stuppnig, said the court’s ruling will increase limits and controls on Meta’s data-gathering.

"Meta has basically been building a huge data pool on users for 20 years now, and it is growing every day," Raabe-Stuppnig said in a statement, according to ABC News. "However, EU law requires 'data minimisation' ... following this ruling, only a small part of Meta’s data pool will be allowed to be used for advertising — even when users consent to ads."

Schrems' claims may seem like small potatoes. But there are enormous safety risks for LGBTQ+ people online if they are outed by targeted ads, especially in countries where homosexuality and bisexuality is illegal, and transgender people are already targeted for violence.

There may be money to be made by tech companies from deducing someone’s sexual orientation — since that individual may be more prone to buy certain goods and services — companies cannot put people’s lives and livelihoods at risk for that financial advantage, at least in the EU.

Neal Broverman
Neal Broverman
Enterprise Editor

Neal joined Mashable’s Social Good team in 2024, editing and writing stories about digital culture and its effects on the environment and marginalized communities. He is the former editorial director of The Advocate and Out magazines, has contributed to the Los Angeles Times, Curbed, and Los Angeles magazine, and is a recipient of the Sarah Pettit Memorial Award for LGBTQ Journalist of the Year Award from the National Gay and Lesbian Journalists Association (NLGJA). He lives in Los Angeles with his family.


Recommended For You
How does orientation affect the dating app experience?
The cover of "The Love Fix" beside an image of the author Rachel Thompson on a pink background covered in ribbons and sparkles.

Supreme Court must halt TikTok ban, ACLU argues
A phone shows the TikTok logo while resting on a dimly lit keyboard.

Get your floors party-ready: 40% (or more) off floor care at Target, including robot vacuums
Three vacuum cleaners on a pink background: a red Dyson cordless stick vacuum, a black Shark robot vacuum with self-empty base, and a blue Shark Navigator Lift-Away upright vacuum.

Get a $15 Target gift card just for stocking up on essentials
Bounty paper towels, Dawn dishwashing soap, and Scott paper towels against a blue background.

Stock up on bedtime stories with buy 2, get one free one select kids' books at Target
Two kids' books on purple and blue abstract background

More in Tech

I'm grabbing the Apple Watch Series 10 for under $300 at Amazon, saving $100
Apple Watch Series 10 (GPS, 42mm) on a white patterned background

The Bose Smart Soundbar 550 is under $200 at Walmart. My ears are ready.
Bose Smart Soundbar 550 on a white patterned background

I've just scored Apple’s 10th-Gen iPad for under $260 at Amazon. That’s its lowest price in 30 days.
Apple iPad on blue background

Stock up on free indie books in the latest Stuff Your Kindle Day
Selection of books covers

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for March 7, 2025
A close-up of an NYT Connections game on a smartphone.

NYT Strands hints, answers for March 7
A game being played on a smartphone.

Wordle today: Answer, hints for March 7, 2025
A close-up of a Wordle game open on a smartphone.

Why are there no iPhones in 'Severance'?
By Jake Kleinman
John Turturro in "Severance."

NYT Mini crossword answers, hints for March 7, 2025
Close-up view of crossword puzzle.
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!